Tuesday, June 26, 2007

Can men and women be friends?


This question was raised in the 1989 film, When Harry Met Sally. Today we ask it again. Can men and women be friends? Here is my short answer. Yes...as long as they both realize and accept that the friendship will evolve as life circumstances change. We could leave it at that and move on to the next topic, but we would miss out on all of the good stuff that I know we really want to talk about anyway. So let me go ahead and give you my long answer.

When we say that a man and woman become friends, I think we are able to fit that friendship into three categories.
  1. They are both attracted to each other
  2. One is attracted to the other, but not both
  3. Neither is attracted the other

Let me also further define what I mean by "attraction". For this purpose we are talking about physical attraction exclusively. We have already established that there is a friendship, so by definition we can assume that this couple enjoys each other's company and desires to spend time together. So now we can look at the affects that each of these categories has on the relationship.

1. If both are attracted to each other then there will almost always be that time when they "hook up". Sometimes this turns into the "friends with benefits". For whatever reason, the couple determines that they are better off as friends. This obviously creates issues within the relationship and boundaries will need to be defined as the friendship develops.

2. If only one is attracted to the other then there is great potential for that person to get hurt, even unintentionally. There will always be that remnant of hope that things could change within the relationship. More often than not, it won't change and the success of the relationship will be balanced on the no-nonsense communication that is shared.

3. If by chance neither person finds the other physically attractive, then the relationship is free to grow, void of the poisons of lust. I would venture to say that these are the relationships that are the healthiest and most carefree.

Having said all this...I think the most crucial part in the entire relationship is having the understanding that things will (and should) change as soon as one gets involved with another person. Again, I am talking about friendships that are more than just casual acquaintances. One of the most dangerous things in a dating or married relationship is jealousy. Your partner should be the one you choose to spend the most time with. He/she should be your top priority. In fact, I know many couples who have established boundaries within the relationship making time alone with someone from the opposite sex a no no. For them, it is not about lack of trust. Rather, it is about carefully guarding the relationship and strengthening the level of commitment to each other. I believe that those boundaries can only be defined by the couple. But I do believe that in most relationships, if not all, the opposite sex friendships have evolved into something new at this point.



For our friends, Harry and Sally...well, they realized that their friendship was all they needed in life. In fact, I don't think they could have lived without each other. Which reminds me...my friend John once said that to find someone who you could live with is one thing, but to find someone who you cannot live without...well, that is love.

10 comments:

Rambling Realist said...

I agree...but I do think that if two people fall into the third category then they can truly be friends and spend time alone - lunch, etc. I guess maybe because I've had several guy friends my whole life and we've managed to keep things platonic and 9 times out of 10 their girlfriends or wives have trusted them alone with me. I think the big thing here is communication with your significant other and trust in them. if you two agree on those boundaries and you trust each other you can allow them alone time with friends of the opposite sex. I do realize that temptation can be great and all that...but I guess it's a risk/chance I'm willing to take to have freedom myself. If you can't trust your friends and your spouses friends then who can you trust???

Billy said...

I agree that trust should be part of the foundation of any healthy relationship. You should be able to trust close friends and your spouse. However, the point being made has to do with closely guarding your marriage...to always be above reproach. I know many pastors who even leave the door to their office open if they are meeting with the opposite gender. Certainly I would say that their spouse trusts them. Ultimately, I believe that this is one of those situations that only a husband and wife can define for themselves. Perhaps it is different for each friendship. As always, open communication is the key in the couple identifying which boundaries should be drawn.

Billy said...

...also, keep in mind that I am just coming out of a marriage so I have a different approach on this right now than someone, say, who is not married or who has never been married. Again, I'll reinforce that this is one of those things that the couple will decide for themselves.

Go 49ers! I just had to throw that in there. I'm a big San Francisco fan.

Rambling Realist said...

I think your recent situation definitely will influence how you feel about this topic...go Chiefs!!!!!!!!!!!! :-)

Unknown said...

"void of the poisons of lust" -- overly strong language there when you're dealing with physical attraction of all kinds (not all physical attraction is lustful, or probably more true, most physical attraction is not lustful) but a good turn of phrase regardless

bethlynn said...

Oh.... I have to agree that there should be bounderies set in place when in a commited relationship/marriage. While we may trust our spouse completely, if one is put in a situation where tempation could potentially arise.... your flirting with danger. In all honesty, your husband/wife should be your best friend, confidant. I'd have to be honest, when one has never been in the situation of having been betrayed by your own spouse.... it's very easy to say that it's not a big deal, but for me personally it's been lessons learned.

Anonymous said...

I've been exploring for a bit for any high quality articles or weblog posts in this kind of area . Exploring in Yahoo I finally stumbled upon this web site. Studying this information So i am satisfied to convey that I've a very good uncanny feeling I discovered
just what I needed. I such a lot indubitably will make sure to don?
t put out of your mind this website and give it a glance regularly.



my web site: sizzling hot 199 games

Anonymous said...

Hi! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with Search Engine Optimization?
I'm trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I'm not
seeing very good gains. If you know of any please share.

Kudos!

Here is my web blog ... stargames gutschein

Anonymous said...

certainly like your web-site however you have to check the spelling on several of your
posts. A number of them are rife with spelling
problems and I find it very bothersome to inform the reality on the other hand I'll certainly come again again.

my website; novostar spiele

Anonymous said...

It's impressive that you are getting ideas from this piece of writing as well as from our discussion made here.

Look into my blog bok of ra